Hospitals Extra to Blame Than the Pandemic for Nurse Staffing Woes?

Hospitals Extra to Blame Than the Pandemic for Nurse Staffing Woes?

The pandemic was not the “root trigger” of hospitals’ issues recruiting and retaining nurses however, reasonably, a “contributing issue,” stated the authors of a cross-sectional research of registered nurses in two states.

Excessive ranges of nurse burnout, job dissatisfaction, and intent to depart their employer predated the pandemic, reported Linda Aiken, PhD, RN, founding director on the Middle for Well being Outcomes and Coverage Analysis on the College of Pennsylvania Faculty of Nursing in Philadelphia, and colleagues.

“The pandemic did not trigger [these problems],” Aiken instructed MedPage In the present day. “This stuff have been actually dangerous earlier than COVID, they usually obtained a little bit bit worse.”

The research underscores the necessity for insurance policies to forestall persistent understaffing of nurses in hospitals, Aiken’s group wrote of their paper in Nursing Outlook.

“The primary takeaway is that higher staffed hospitals earlier than the pandemic had higher outcomes throughout it, and proceed to have higher outcomes as time goes on,” Aiken stated.

Previous to the pandemic, 57% of hospital workers nurses stated there have been too few nurses to take care of sufferers; that quantity grew to 67% throughout the pandemic.

Nevertheless, the excessive proportion of nurses who reported burnout grew solely 3 share factors after greater than 1 yr of the pandemic (51% vs 48% previous to the pandemic).

Nor was there “proof that enormous numbers of nurses left healthcare or hospital apply within the first 18 months of the pandemic,” the researchers discovered. Evaluating pre-pandemic survey knowledge with knowledge collected throughout the pandemic, the share of nurses employed in hospitals didn’t differ by greater than a fraction of 1% (43.9% vs 43.7%, P=0.322).

“All this enterprise of individuals throwing up their arms and saying ‘There aren’t nurses to rent as a result of they’ve all left’ [is] not likely true,” she stated.

Whereas there was a number of “disruption” and plenty of nurses have modified employers, “leaving your employer is just not the identical as leaving the sphere of affected person care and even leaving hospitals,” Aiken harassed.

As well as, the share of nurses reporting they have been “not assured in administration resolving scientific care issues” grew throughout the pandemic from 69.4% to 77.5% (P<0.001), charges Aiken known as surprising.

“You might see that it might be very demoralizing if three-quarters of all of the nurses that you simply work with have completely no confidence that high administration is setting a precedence on the issues that you’re actually invested in as a clinician,” she stated.

“That is on the coronary heart of the burnout, and the job dissatisfaction and all the turnover in hospitals,” Aiken advised.

Staffing Ratios

Moreover, the group discovered that nurses with decrease patient-to-nurse staffing ratios previous to the pandemic had decrease charges of a variety of detrimental outlooks throughout the pandemic. Nurses with a pre-pandemic patient-to-nurse ratio of 5 or much less have been much less prone to endorse the next in contrast with those that had a ratio of six or extra:

  • Job dissatisfaction (25.1% vs 35%)
  • Unfavorable affected person security grades (33.9% vs 54.6% )
  • Poor or truthful high quality of care (15.7% vs 33.0%)
  • Administration would not pay attention or reply to nurses’ issues (44% vs 58.2%)

That “deep chasm” in confidence in hospital administration may need been as a result of furloughs and layoffs of nurses throughout the pandemic, resulting in a lack of confidence that hospitals actually had sufferers’ pursuits at coronary heart, Aiken advised.

“As nurses lose their sense of loyalty to a person hospital that simply creates this type of revolving door the place folks preserve occurring to the following finest provide,” Aiken stated.

Except they will bridge that hole in confidence, hospitals will not reach bringing nurses again, she added.

One silver lining was a discovering of “superb” relations between medical doctors and nurses, Aiken stated. The share of nurses reporting that there’s “not a number of nurse-physician teamwork” really declined throughout the pandemic from 18.9% to fifteen.1%.

The findings suggest that fixing hospitals’ nursing care shortages would possibly take “committing extra of their finances to using full time nurses and enhancing their work surroundings,” Aiken stated, which may be achieved by participating extra clinicians in decision-making, providing extra versatile scheduling and committing to creating their workforce.

“Everyone desires the nurse with 10 years of ICU expertise once they come within the door,” Aiken stated, however “profitable organizations develop their very own work forces and put money into younger folks and assist them to grow to be specialists over time after which create insurance policies to retain them.”

Coverage levers like nursing staffing requirements are additionally essential to contemplate, she added, pointing to the success of California’s implementation of staffing ratios some 20 years in the past.

“However no different state has been in a position to do it since,” she stated, due to robust resistance from the hospital trade.

As a substitute of counting on states, Aiken advised trying to the federal authorities for assist. Medicare, as an example, may make staffing ranges extra clear by requiring all hospitals that take part in this system to publicly report their nursing ratios on the Hospital Examine web site or just mandate minimal nurse staffing requirements, she advised.

Methodology and Limitations

The cross-sectional research was based mostly on surveys of 151,335 registered nurses in New York and Illinois, together with a subset of 40,674 workers nurses working at 357 hospitals, representing 99% of all services in these states.

Information have been collected through an internet survey throughout the prepandemic interval from Dec. 16, 2019, to Feb. 24, 2020, and throughout the pandemic from April 13, 2021, to June 22, 2021.

All registered nurses with energetic licenses in New York and Illinois have been invited to take the survey. Roughly 81,263 nurses participated pre-pandemic and 70,072 participated throughout the pandemic, for response charges of 18% and 14%, respectively.

Respondents have been requested whether or not they have been presently employed in a healthcare place at a hospital, employed in a healthcare place however not in a hospital, employed however not in healthcare, not presently employed, or retired.

As a result of the research measures have been carried out at solely two time limits, the authors warned in opposition to drawing causal inferences. The survey response charges have been additionally “not optimum” they wrote, though “not out of line” with different massive on-line surveys.

Different limitations have been that the pandemic-era surveys won’t have been consultant of all the pandemic, with additional adjustments attainable because the time of completion, and the variety of overlapping respondents who participated in each rounds of surveys was unknown.

  • author['full_name']

    Shannon Firth has been reporting on well being coverage as MedPage In the present day’s Washington correspondent since 2014. She can be a member of the location’s Enterprise & Investigative Reporting crew. Follow


The research was supported by the Nationwide Council on State Boards of Nursing, the Nationwide Institute of Nursing Analysis, NIH, and the Company for Healthcare Analysis and High quality.

The authors reported no conflicts of curiosity.

Main Supply

Nursing Outlook

Supply Reference: Aiken, LH et al “A repeated cross-sectional research of nurses instantly earlier than and throughout the Covid-19 pandemic: Implications for motion” Nursing Outlook 2022; DOI:10.1016/j.outlook.2022.11.007.